Select Page

The Big Benboozle

African-American voters see through Carson's alternative history
by D.R. Tucker

Oct 27, 2015 | Media, Politics



Ben Carson may be a renowned doctor, but even he cannot perform surgery on history.

When the soft-spoken Islamophobic surgeon, critic of the modern civil-rights movement and top contender for the Republican presidential nomination, appeared on Fox News Channel’s Media Buzz as he began to climb in the polls, he declared that the GOP “has a very excellent opportunity by paying attention to some of the communities that they have neglected. And informing them about the history of the GOP. . . .”

Carson serves an important purpose in the Republican Party, but it’s unlikely that telling neglected communities about his party’s history is one of them. That history involves betrayal as well as neglect.

Prior to Barry Goldwater’s 1964 presidential campaign and his repudiation of the Civil Rights Act, Republicans could compete with Democrats for black votes. Magazine editor and columnist George Curry addressed that history from an African-American perspective in 2009:

Blacks, most of whom lived in the South, supported the Republican Party not only because of Lincoln, but also because virulent white segregationist politicians in the South were Democrats.

Although Presidents Franklin D. Roosevelt and Harry Truman were able to attract a growing share of the African-American vote in the 1930s and 1940s, the “Party of Lincoln” could secure significant numbers of black votes as late as the 1960 Presidential campaign.

Then Goldwater geared his campaign toward Southern bigots livid over civil rights advances, causing a dramatic shift to the right within the GOP. In his 2006 autobiography Bridging the Divide, the late Massachusetts Senator Edward Brooke––a moderate Republican who in 1966 became the first African-American elected to the Senate by popular vote, serving two terms before losing a 1978 reelection bid––observed that at the 1964 Republican National Convention in San Francisco:

[W]e moderates were outgunned. We saw our party taken over by zealous right-wingers. Their racial views would have appalled Abraham Lincoln. . . . The archconservatives who had rallied around Barry Goldwater did not believe that equal access to schools, hospitals, restaurants, and hotels were basic American rights. A tragic result of their ascendance was that the party of Lincoln did not back the Civil Rights Act of 1964. . . . [A]fter Goldwater [opposed the Civil Rights Act] it was difficult, if not impossible, for a black Republican like myself to recruit other blacks into the Republican Party.

Sixteen years after Goldwater lost in a landslide, his “states-rights” acolyte Ronald Reagan became the 40th president. Reagan and the New Right understood that in order to reverse what they considered the civil-rights excesses of the 1960s and 1970s (i.e., affirmative action and desegregation busing), it would help to have a few prominent faces of color inside and outside the administration promoting the idea that social racism had declined, and that there was no longer a need to have Big Government push for “equality of result.” Thus emerged Reagan’s recruited reactionaries of color, such as Equal Employment Opportunity Commission Chairman (and future Supreme Court Justice) Clarence Thomas and U.S. Commission on Civil Rights Chairman Clarence Pendleton, as well as economists and Reagan cheerleaders Thomas Sowell and Walter Williams.

As GOP race-baiting continued into the 1990s, 2000s, and 2010s, it became ever more important to have a black face or two peddling the message that racism was on the decline and that civil rights protections were no longer needed. This was Alan Keyes’s message in his 1996 and 2000 campaigns for president. This was Herman Cain’s message (well, that and “9-9-9”) in his shambolic 2012 campaign for president. This is the core of Ben Carson’s message in his 2016 campaign for president.

African-American voters have seen through this charade, as evidenced by the strong black voter support for Bill Clinton, Al Gore, John Kerry, and Barack Obama. This black-conservative bamboozling is as transparent as the diversity show that was the infamous 2000 Republican National Convention in Philadelphia: a desperate attempt to convince the gullible that the Southern Strategy never really existed, that black education and employment opportunities are equal to those of whites, that police brutality and unequal access to quality health care are fictional problems, and that government bureaucrats are the real opponents of racial equality.

The American right needs its fantasies, and needs its hirelings to tell them those fantasies are real. Thomas, Sowell, Williams, Keyes, Cain, and Carson play the same role on race that climate deniers play on energy: insisting that we don’t have a problem and that anyone who says we do is lying. By playing this role, they’re keeping the con in conservatism.


Photo Credit: Gage Skidmore

D.R. Tucker is a Massachusetts-based freelance writer and contributor to The Washington Monthly blog.

Read On:

Share This Story:


  1. They must really think that African Americans are as stupid as their unhinged tea party base but I assure them WE ARE NOT! They can trotted as many sellout black conservatives as they want but they will still be lucky if they get 10% of the black vote.

  2. The con is not to convince black people to vote Republican, the con is to convince gullible white moderates and conservatives that there is nothing racist about today’s Republican party.

  3. The analogy to climate change denying scientists is apt. Likewise, no self respecting doctor would swear there was no lick between cancer and tobacco and no self respecting African American would embrace the policies of today’s Republicans, but if you are willing to sell your soul, the market is willing to offer lucrative compensation.

  4. The title suggests that Ben Carson said something misleading about political history, but the only quotation by Carson that the article offers is the one stating that the GOP needs to listen to parties that it has neglected. Blacks in the United States have not enjoyed equal access to education, jobs, and other opportunities, but it was always the Democrats who supported slavery in the U.S., subjecting blacks to poverty for lifetimes to come. The fact that blacks have been oppressed in American society began with Democrats’ oppression of them when they enslaved Africans. Republicans haven’t connected to black communities in the United States or offered clear solutions specific to their issues of inequality, but they also haven’t manipulated the black community in order to preserve their political power. After all, it was Johnson, a Democrat, who notoriously said, “I’ll have those n* voting democratic for the next 200 years.”

We collect email addresses for the sole purpose of communicating more efficiently with our Washington Spectator readers and Public Concern Foundation supporters.  We will never sell or give your email address to any 3rd party.  We will always give you a chance to opt out of receiving future emails, but if you’d like to control what emails you get, just click here.