Join The Washington Spectator community today Sign Up Now

Select Page

Of Dogs and People

At the Eurozone table, Deutschlanders stiff the Greek waiters
by Marcel Ophüls

Jul 23, 2015 | Foreign Policy, Politics



Switzerland is a great country, if you like mountains, lakes, secret bank accounts, especially at 2,100 meters altitude, with a view of Monte Rosa and the Matterhorn, which I once climbed as a college kid—ages ago in 1948. As it happens, as I write, it is the 150th anniversary in Zermatt of the day when Edward Whymper allegedly cut the rope on his Swiss Sherpa.

Nowadays, the Swiss are so well organized, so industrious, so friendly, so neutral, so well off, and so goddamn neat!

For example: just yesterday, I was taking Léon, my beautiful white shepherd dog, who is almost as old as I am, for his daily outing. The Helvetican Confederation provides its visitors with special poop bags located every 200 yards or so on streets and in parks. Léon is a Pyrenean Shepherd, so he feels fine at high altitudes, and contributes plenty to the environment as far as pooping is concerned. As he was sitting down for the third time in very high grass, a young German blonde happened to walk by, and spoke to me very sharply and disagreeably: “Ja, was machen Sie denn da? Vhy don’t you bick it op? Unverschamt! Schamlos!” Of course, I pretended not to understand her language, so eventually she walked on, shaking her head, obviously very angry.

Among arrogant right-wing German voters, self-regard, collective egotism, extreme nationalism, and a good deal of racism seem on the march once again. Achtung! Achtung! Niemand verlasst das Lokal.

It gave me something to think about. Why do Germans, I wondered, often feel so self-righteous, so virtuous? Why do they love so much playing policeman to the rest of the world, and telling other people what to do? On the other hand, why are blonde and blue-eyed “Aryan” females so attractive to half-witted, half-Jews like me? Well, never mind about that …

Why do so many Germans feel they work much harder than the Greeks, that they deserve every penny they earn at the sweat of their brow, and that the Greeks and other Mediterranean folks are just good enough to wait on them or make their beds when they are on vacation? Haven’t they learned anything in school? Haven’t they been taught that their famous Wirtschaftswunder was built almost entirely on the Marshall Plan and American postwar generosity toward a vanquished people, which chose to forget most of the German debt? God knows that those hardworking folks didn’t rebuild the ruins of World War II all by themselves.

There’s another chapter in contemporary history that well-meaning young Germans might do well to remember, the regime of the Greek colonels, one of the most brutal and racist dictatorships in postwar Europe, largely brought to power by the United States, i.e., the CIA, with a good deal of help from Germany. In my friend Costa-Gavras’ wonderful movie Z, near the end, as one of the colonels is being dragged off to jail, a journalist asks: “Do you feel a little like Dreyfus, sir?” And the colonel shouts back: “But Dreyfus was guilty!”

But then, there’s a persistent rumor that a far more famous military man of the past century also thought that nearsighted little Jewish captain was guilty. Charles de Gaulle in London, in 1940, when he was waiting for Frenchmen to rally to his cause, he complained: “Here I am waiting for generals and admirals to cross the channel, and all I get is Jews!”

Great sense of humor, if you ask me, but who’s asking?

Let’s get back to the present crisis. If you push people into misery, if you hurt their pride and their dignity, if you take away their Lebensraum, surely they will turn to some sort of savior, some kind of Fuhrer to pull them out of trouble. Let’s not forget that Hitler was democratically elected not so very long ago.

Austerity, my foot! Weeks ago, when they still believed they controlled their destiny, Alexis Tsipras and his people were perfectly right to vote NEIN! A bas Frau Merkel, the Teutonic Margaret Thatcher! There’s not a very long way from her to the anti-poop lady I met in the hills. Granted that Onassis was very very rich, while Papandreous seems more than a little corrupt, not to speak of Caramanlis, and they probably have secret bank accounts with the gnomes in Zurich, but among arrogant right-wing German voters, self-regard, collective egotism, extreme nationalism, and a good deal of racism seem on the march once again. Achtung! Achtung! Niemand verlasst das Lokal.

The new Greek finance minister turns out to be an Oxford graduate, and a disciple of John Maynard Keynes. Fine! Maybe he can teach Angela Merkel something about real economics. Nobody, I’m afraid, can teach her Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble about anything.

Marcel Ophüls is a director and filmmaker best known for his trilogy of epic post-Holocaust documentaries—The Sorrow and the Pity (1969); The Memory of Justice (1976), newly restored and featured this year at the upcoming New York Film Festival, and Hotel Terminus: the Life and Times of Klaus Barbie (1988), which won the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature.

Read On:

Share This Story:


  1. Extraordinary Ophuls quote. I am a whole Jew, half of whose family was gassed in Auschwitz while the other half led very comfy lives, like the Swiss then and now. Distressing the extent to which the victim identifies with the aggressor on all continents. Blake’s “The cut worm loves the plow.” To the extent we’ve been damaged in our youth we have a hierarchy in our bones. Frightening though not surprising De Gaulle quote. Continuing congratulations on your excellent work. ML

  2. The reference to the Marshall Plan reminds of my experience in Salzburg, Austria in 1962, when we stayed at a little inn on Arthur Frommer’s list of places to stay for $5 a day. There was a plaque in the lobby thanking the Marshall Plan for enabling the owners to rebuild their damaged inn after the war. Good people.

  3. What an incredible stupid article. Was a lot of the Greek depth forgiven already? Yes! Was it more than the Marshall plan? Yes! Does the current situation have anything to do with WW2? No! Would it help Greece to get money without reforms? No! Does the author have the slightest clue of European policy? No.
    Crying WW2 whenever you disagree with German policy is crazy. I will tell my 11 year old boy that he will never be allowed to think for himself because his greatgrandfather happened to live in Germany during WW2.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We collect email addresses for the sole purpose of communicating more efficiently with our Washington Spectator readers and Public Concern Foundation supporters.  We will never sell or give your email address to any 3rd party.  We will always give you a chance to opt out of receiving future emails, but if you’d like to control what emails you get, just click here.

Send this to a friend